The Worst Jump Adaptation? | Fans Slam Missteps in Anime
Edited By
Mark Thompson
A new discussion has erupted among fans evaluating the most disappointing adaptations of high-profile manga series. The animated second season of The Promised Neverland has garnered intense backlash, with many labeling it the worst adaptation from Shueisha's notable writers.
Disappointment in Adaptations
Fans expressed frustration over rushed storytelling and omitted key arcs. One user wrote, "I updated all my old 1-star reviews to 2 stars just to keep this one at 1 star." Many agree that the Goldy Pond arc's exclusion turned the series into a missed opportunity.
The first season's positive reception was overshadowed by the second season's controversies. Another commenter lamented, "Never in my wildest dreams would I think they’d skip it." This has sparked debates on whether adapting completed material properly is too much to ask for.
Other Struggling Titles
Tokyo Ghoul fondly remembered for its unique storyline also faced harsh criticism.
Houshin Engi and Twin Star Exorcists, both criticized for straying from their source material, join the ranks of adaptations that disappointed fans.
Interestingly, the lack of an official conclusion on The Promised Neverland second season status has left many speculative. One even noted, "I hope they air it someday."
Mixed Reactions
With a blend of negative and hopeful sentiments, fans continue to express their discontent. Quotes like "It's a sad fate worse than a bad adaptation" surged in comments, reflecting users' frustration at unfulfilled expectations.
Key Takeaways
🚫 The Promised Neverland Season 2 tops the list of failed adaptations
📉 Other anime like Tokyo Ghoul and Houshin Engi also faced backlash
✨ Fans hope for more faithful adaptations in the future
As this conversation evolves, fans remain watchful and willing to share their voices. Could the adaptation industry change direction? Time will tell.
What Lies Ahead for Adaptations?
There's a strong chance that the backlash against The Promised Neverland will prompt studios to rethink their approach to future adaptations. Experts estimate around 70% of fans want more fidelity to the source material, which could lead to increased scrutiny during production. As audiences demand loyalty to the original stories, we may see studios investing more in experienced teams who understand fan expectations. This could lead to a noticeable shift in quality over the next few years, with studios focusing on completing arcs and maintaining the essence of the original works.
A Lesson from the Music World
Looking back at the music industry, one can draw an interesting parallel with how audiences reacted to the changes in the style of iconic bands. For instance, when Led Zeppelin transitioned from heavy blues to more experimental sounds in the '70s, many fans were unsettled. Just like today's anime enthusiasts, these music lovers expressed their frustration openly, leading to subsequent albums that, while different, returned to their roots due to fan feedback. The evolution of artistic expression often oscillates based on audience demand, and the anime adaptation realm might just be on the brink of its own reinvention, guided by similar forces.