Heavy Discourse | Fans Clash Over Parenting in Popular Manga
Edited By
Jamal El-Masri
A lively debate is heating up among fans regarding the portrayal of parenting roles in a leading manga series. The discussion, sparked by recent comments in forums, raises questions about the moral implications of various characters' actions. This has led to a mix of heated opinions and unexpected insights.
Garp vs. Roger: Differing Views on Parenting
When it comes to relationships within the series, two names stand out: Garp and Roger. Users are divided on how they rank these characters as fathers.
One fan commented, "It's best dad, not grandpa," emphasizing the lack of clarity in Garp's relationship with Dragon.
Another user expressed concern, stating, "To put Roger on the same level as Dragon and Yassop seems harsh. He gave his son to Garp while battling cancer."
The dialogue highlights a larger conflict: Can a character still be deemed a good parent if they are absent due to health issues or choices made during their life?
Controversy Surrounding Garp
Criticism of Garp has emerged as a notable theme. Comments point to his treatment of Luffy and Ace, with one stating, "Garp is a genuine child abuser, get him out of better than most."
This negative sentiment is echoed by others questioning his parenting methods, particularly considering his role during Ace's execution.
In contrast, some argue, "As much as I hate this guy, I gotta admit he was actually an okay dad considering how low OP standards are for parental figures."
The Broader Implications of Parentage in Fandom
Fans are not just focusing on Garp and Roger. They are also comparing their actions to other parental figures within the manga. Commenters are asking why certain characters are considered better than others, revealing a deeper conversation about expectations in storytelling.
"Roger's placement depends on how he influenced not just Ace but also Shanks and Buggy. They're like his 'sons' too," one commenter noted.
Key Insights
📌 Garp's character receives mixed reviews regarding his parenting.
🔍 Fans criticize the portrayal of Roger’s decisions during his illness.
⚖️ The debate underscores larger themes of parental responsibility in the storyline.
As this conversation evolves, one begins to wonder: Can audiences truly separate a character's greatness from their personal life choices? Share your thoughts in the forums.