Top 10 Seinen Manga | Anilist Scores Spark Fan Debates

A fresh Top 10 list of Seinen manga based on Anilist's Mean Score ratings has ignited passionate discussions among fans. This ranking challenges the status quo, stirring controversy, especially regarding the placement of Grand Blue over 20th Century Boys.

Rankings Context and Methodology

An aficionado utilized Anilist's ratings to curate a list of original Seinen titles, excluding adaptations and those with fewer than 3-6 million copies sold. According to their criteria, the following iconic works made the cut:

1. Berserk | 93%

2. JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Steel Ball Run | 92%

3. Vagabond | 91%

4. Monster | 90%

5. Vinland Saga | 90%

6. Kingdom | 89%

7. Vagabond: Saigo no Manga ten | 89%

8. Real | 89%

9. Grand Blue | 89%

10. 20th Century Boys | 88%

Controversial Entries Highlighted

Despite most titles receiving approval, Grand Blue has emerged as a focal point for dissent. One user remarked, "Bruh said never heard of Grand Blue, never read it but apparently knows for a fact it doesn’t deserve its spot." This reflects a wider sentiment, as many fans are grappling with how humor's appeal can influence ratings.

Additionally, some questioned the mixing of Western audiences with Japanese sales numbers, suggesting a disconnect in how rankings are perceived. As one commenter noted, "I fail to see the point of mixing (a particular) Western audience and Japanese sales this way."

Diverse Opinions Fuel the Debate

Feedback emphasizes the list's subjectivity and the clash between critical acclaim and personal taste. Noteworthy comments include:

• "My own Top 10 is not based on what I like the most, but what I deem as critically and narratively best."

• "This metric is still partly based on subjectivity."

• "Was hoping fable would've been here but I guess it's not as popular."

The interplay of personal connections to titles has created a mixed emotional landscape for fans, whereby critical perceptions often differ from individual experiences.

Key Takeaways

• 🔢 60% of titles align in both lists, including the #1 pick.

• 🎭 Users express concern about balancing humor with critical acclaim.

• 🗣️ "Grand Blue is super funny though" illustrates the variance in enjoyment levels.

With contentious views continuing to swirl, can fandom truly agree on what defines the best in manga? This ongoing analysis of the Top 10 rankings reveals not just a battle of opinions, but also a deeper reflection on the changing tastes within the community.