MangaNights Logo

MangaNights

Home
/
Fandom news
/
Fandom guides
/

Is this tier list still relevant after a year?

Arc Rankings Ignite Debate | Fans React to Year-Old Tier List

By

Fatima Noor

Mar 19, 2026, 03:34 AM

Edited By

Liam O'Reilly

Updated

Mar 19, 2026, 04:26 PM

A blink of an eye read

A group of people discussing and sharing opinions about a tier list at a round table

A recent discussion among fans has erupted over a year-old tier list ranking anime arcs, igniting passionate debates on forums. This renewed interest comes as people express strong opinions on the merits of various series arcs, leading to a lively exchange of ideas.

Tier List Controversy Continues

The excitement sparked when a fan shared their tier list, including placements that have since been heavily scrutinized. For instance, Davy Back Fight is still a hot topic, with many declaring it among the weakest arcs. One fan remarked, > "Davy Back Fight was ass. Only good part was Aokiji," fueling ongoing arguments about its value. Notably, several commenters defended the tier placement of other arcs, such as LRLL, with one saying, "LRLL at C is criminal. It’s a really underrated arc" This illustrates the divide in opinions.

New Insights Emerge

Fans are diving deeper into more arcs:

  • Orange Town: Some are perplexed by the negativity surrounding it, questioning why others have disdain for this arc.

  • Dressrosa, Amazon Lily, and Zou: Commenters hailed these arcs as 10/10, expressing frustration at their perceived undervaluation.

  • Thriller Bark: This arc faced criticism, with one commenter asserting, "People don’t hate Thriller Bark enough."

Notable Quotes

  • "Amazon Lily should be at the very least A"

  • "Saboady is S Tier better than Marineford"

  • "The beginning of the arc is so funny with the crew discovering Brook"

Sentiments among fans remain mixed, showcasing a blend of enthusiasm and disagreement.

Key Takeaways

  • ◻️ Diverse Opinions: Strong views on arcs like Orange Town and Thriller Bark illustrate varied fan perceptions.

  • ◼️ Quality Debates: Ongoing discourse about placements reflects differing standards and expectations from the anime community.

  • ◽️ Engagement Rising: The passionate arguments may lead to more fan-created content, including new tier lists and collaborative projects.

Fans remain dedicated to debating their favorite arcs, demonstrating the ongoing vitality of anime culture. Expect more conversations and possibly fresh rankings as engagement from this discussion continues.