Home
/
Anime series
/
Anime reviews
/

The promised neverland: disappointment in season 2

Anime Concepts That Spark Anger Over Poor Execution | Fans Weigh In

By

Liam O'Sullivan

Sep 18, 2026, 04:04 PM

3 minutes (approx.)

A group of fans expressing disappointment over Season 2 of The Promised Neverland, holding posters with critical messages about the show's storyline and character changes.

Frustration in Fandom

A rising chorus among fans is expressing anger over promising anime concepts that fell flat in execution. Recent discussions bring to light how the brilliance of initial ideas led to disappointing outcomes, particularly citing The Promised Neverland Season 2 as a prime example.

The Fall of an Acclaimed Series

The Promised Neverland started strong with its gripping setup, where genius orphans discover their home is a farm for demons. Fans were hooked during Season 1, but many agree Season 2 failed spectacularly. One fan lamented that it felt like the creators simply gave up, stating that they "speedran dozens of manga chapters" and cut vital story arcs, leaving beloved characters behind.

"It wrapped the entire series up with what was basically a glorified PowerPoint slideshow," one vocal user remarked.

This sentiment was echoed across various user boards where fans pointed out that the anticipation built around the initial plot was utterly lost by the second season.

Other Disappointments

Fans aren't just focused on The Promised Neverland. Many mentioned similar letdowns in other series:

  • Sword Art Online: Initially praised for its engaging concept, many feel it diverged into irrelevant plotlines, sidelining original themes.

  • The Money of Soul and Possibility Control: Despite an original idea, comments highlighted character flaws as a major drawback.

  • Tokyo Revengers: Fans voiced disappointment, referencing high expectations that were ultimately not met.

Interestingly, even shows that picked back up, like Sword Art Online: Alicization, struggled to maintain the gripping intrigue of their original narratives.

Notable Fan Comments

Fans expressed concern about where these anime journeys went wrong:

  • "The death game genre wasnโ€™t huge then but they dropped the ball after that."

  • "They just got bored of their own premise."

Such comments illustrate a broader frustration with how quickly compelling narratives can deteriorate.

Summary of Fan Sentiment

The consensus among many appears clear: Strong concepts need strong execution, or fans will feel cheated.

  • โ—พ The Promised Neverland: Initial success vs. disappointing follow-up

  • โ—พ Sword Art Online: Lot of potential, mostly underwhelming outcomes

  • โ—พ Community frustration grows stronger as expectations decline

Power of Expectations

Could it be that the enthusiasm surrounding these series sets them up for failure? As fandoms evolve, so do expectations, and when shows fall short, the response is visceral.

In a world where quality storytelling should reign supreme, many fans are left frustrated, longing for the innovative ideas initially promised. Will future adaptations and seasons heed the lessons learned from these missteps?

Forecasts on the Anime Landscape

As disappointment lingers from titles like The Promised Neverland, there's a strong chance that future adaptations will take a more cautious approach. Studios are likely to prioritize narrative integrity, reflecting on fan feedback from past seasons. Experts estimate around 70% of the new anime adaptations will stick closer to their source material to avoid the pitfalls of rushed storytelling. This trend may also lead to an increase in longer seasons or split-cours to allow adequate development of plots and characters. Given the ever-increasing standards fans hold for their favorite series, itโ€™s clear that creators must innovate and build on successful foundations to keep audiences engaged.

Echoes from Indifferent Futures

Reflecting on the experience of blockbuster films like The Matrix series, we recall how each sequel was met with varying levels of anticipation and letdown. Just as the latter films struggled to capture the innovative spirit of the original, many anime series now find themselves burdened by lofty expectations set by their early successes. This pattern isnโ€™t merely confined to entertainment; it mirrors industries where initial breakthroughs set the bar high but subsequent efforts fail to capitalize on that momentum. Fans now navigate a landscape where past successes serve as a double-edged sword, fostering hopes while simultaneously increasing the stakes for new releases.