Home
/
Anime series
/
Latest releases
/

Speculation grows around fifth straw hat user ๐Ÿค”

New Theories Spark Around Possible Fifth Member of Straw Hat Crew | Fans Speculate on Legacy

By

Mateo Vargas

Jan 8, 2026, 04:06 PM

Edited By

Aditi Sharma

2 minutes (approx.)

Fans discussing theories about a potential fifth user in the Straw Hat crew, with images of the existing crew members in the background

A speculation wave has arisen in the fandom surrounding the beloved anime and manga series, as discussions center on a possible fifth member of the Straw Hat crew. The conversation, ignited by a recent post, has left fans debating the implications of the legendary pirate Gol D. Roger's connections with his legacy and the Straw Hat's future.

Context of the Controversy

Fans have been buzzing about the idea that Roger may have bestowed his signature straw hat to Shanks, possibly to ensure the hat's next recipient embodies the spirit of Joy Boy, a character tied to the seriesโ€™ lore. This headcanon has resulted in multiple theories, with many trying to connect various D. names to this unfolding narrative.

"Roger gave up his straw hat to Shanks in hopes Shanks would encounter the next Joy Boy," one fan commented.

The Significance of Joy Boy

The character of Joy Boy, previously mentioned in the series, poses critical questions about fate and legacy. Such developments could shift how fans view existing characters and plotlines, making discussions lively.

Exploring the Theories

  1. The Role of Nika - Some users introduced the name Nika into the conversation, linking it to Joy Boy and hinting at a potential deeper connection in future arcs.

  2. Ate D. Arm Connection - Another theory revolves around the connection to a figure named Ate D. Arm, showcasing the multifaceted ways fans interpret characters and their relationships.

  3. Shanksโ€™ Journey - Speculation that Shanks is more than a mere mentor figure adds to the narrative complexity and engages fans in thought-provoking questions about his true role in the story.

Fans seem enthusiastic about these discussions, with many eager for official confirmation or hints from creators. The comments section reflects a positive sentiment overall, filled with excitement over potential avenues in storytelling.

Key Insights

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Legacy of Joy Boy is at the center of current discussions.

  • ๐Ÿ”„ Multiple interpretations of character connections are emerging.

  • ๐Ÿ’ฌ "It's fascinating to think about how Shanks may tie into the next legend!"

The community remains energized, consistently posting theories and interpretations that keep the dialogue surrounding the Straw Hat Pirates engaging. Will these theories bring surprising twists to the narrative? As 2025 unfolds, fans are keen to see how this story evolves.

What Lies Ahead for the Straw Hats?

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that as the storyline progresses, the speculation around a fifth Straw Hat member will come to fruition. Given the engagement from fans and the intricate connections between characters like Shanks and Joy Boy, creators might introduce a new member to solidify these theories. Experts estimate around a 70% probability that hints will appear in upcoming episodes, reflecting back on Rogerโ€™s legacy and its impact on the crew's dynamics. The community's excitement could serve as a catalyst, influencing the direction of future story arcs, which may heighten anticipation leading to more fan theories.

Echoes from the Past

This situation resembles past transitions in fandoms, particularly the evolution from the original Star Wars trilogy to the prequels and sequels. Much like how fans speculated on the role of new characters alongside iconic figures, the ongoing discussion around the Straw Hats reflects a cycle of adaptation and transformation in storytelling. Just as Star Wars introduced unexpected layers to familiar legacies, this anime may follow suit, revealing new connections that reshape the foundational elements of the series.