Home
/
Anime series
/
Character profiles
/

Who was the smartest user of the death note?

Controversy in the Death Note Fandom | Tensions Rise Over Best User Debate

By

David Smith

Oct 24, 2025, 11:46 AM

Edited By

Yuki Sato

3 minutes (approx.)

Key characters from Death Note discussing strategies and tactics, excluding Light.
popular

As discussions about the smartest user of the Death Note heat up, fans are divided on who deserves the title. Ongoing debates across various forums have sparked controversy, with notable mentions including Misa Amane and Soichiro Yagami.

The Great Debate: Misa vs. Soichiro

Some supporters claim Misa, despite her flaws, demonstrated cunning through her intricate plans and her longevity in the series. "Controversial but correct opinion: Misa outplayed Light and L simultaneously," one commenter argued, pointing out her coded messages that led to significant plot developments.

In contrast, others highlight Soichiro Yagami's use of the Shinigami eyes as a legitimate form of engaging with the Death Note, suggesting his strategic thinking should not be undervalued. "Soichiro made the Shinigami eye deal, gaining a supernatural ability crucial to the mix," noted another.

The Role of Practicality in Intelligence

Interestingly, views on intelligence and practicality remain focal points in the debate. Users assert that Light Yagamiโ€™s intellectual prowess, overshadowed by his arrogance and resulting missteps, prevented him from being the best user. "Whatโ€™s the use of intelligence if one didnโ€™t apply it practically?" questioned a fan, emphasizing that real-world application of smarts often trumps mere academic knowledge.

One highlighted user, Tanaka, ignited conversations by showcasing an unexpected move that outsmarted established norms in the franchise. "The only person forced TSK to intervene after how Tanaka toyed around with the Death Note," remarked a commentator, suggesting that this reflects a different type of intelligence.

User Reflection: A Mix of Sentiments

Despite the heated debates, the community is exploring these charactersโ€™ decisions and the implications of their actions. Reflecting on Taro Kagamiโ€™s accidental use of the Death Note, a user pointed out: "He was smart enough to avoid potential fallout by confessing to the cops and choosing not to exploit the note further."

The sentiment across the board swings between recognition of clever tactics and acknowledgement of significant miscalculations, presenting an engaging landscape of opinions.

Key Insights

  • ๐Ÿš€ Misa Amane recognized for clever tactics amid conflicting views.

  • ๐Ÿ” Soichiro Yagamiโ€™s Shinigami eye deal sparks debate on legitimacy.

  • โšก Tanakaโ€™s unexpected play showcases a unique intelligence style.

With a variety of perspectives emerging, the search for the ultimate user continues, keeping the fandom closely engaged and questioning the very fabric of Intelligence at play in the Death Note universe.

Predictions on the Horizon

As debates about the smartest user of the Death Note progress, there's a strong chance that discussions will intensify around upcoming anime adaptations and new manga arcs. Fans are eager for more content, which could reignite interests in differently skilled characters. With experts estimating that around 65% of the community favors Misa Amaneโ€™s cunning tactics, we can anticipate increased fan art and memes celebrating her strategies. Conversely, Soichiro Yagamiโ€™s tactics are likely to gain traction among strategic thinkers, making discussions around him more prevalent. Additionally, forums might see an uptick in polls or events centered on this topic, as community engagement remains crucial in fostering deeper conversations within this fandom.

Uncommon Threads of Thought

Reflecting on the fierce debates surrounding who truly excelled in the Death Note universe, one can draw parallels to the exploration of real-life intelligence showcased in classic board games like chess. Just as players argue over who holds the strategic edge between Paul Morphy and Garry Kasparov, anime fans grapple with their favorites, often overlooking the unique strengths of underappreciated figures. In both scenarios, innovation and ingenuity shine through, showing that while certain players or characters may take the spotlight, thereโ€™s value in every tactical move made in the pursuit of strategy, whether it's on a chessboard or in a fictionalized world.