Home
/
Fandom news
/
Community events
/

Who should be the sixth character in the classic series?

Fans Debate Who Should Be the Sixth Character | Is Shaina the Best Choice?

By

Yuki Yamamoto

Aug 29, 2025, 10:55 AM

Edited By

Isabella Cruz

Updated

Aug 30, 2025, 02:35 PM

2 minutes (approx.)

A group of five characters discussing together, with an empty space for a sixth character, representing the fan debate about who should join the classic series.

Anime and manga enthusiasts are firing up discussions on which character should take the sixth spot in a beloved classic series. Ongoing debates on various forums reveal divisions among supporters of both popular and lesser-known characters, igniting passionate exchanges among fans.

Clashing Opinions on Character Selection

The conversation highlights differing viewpoints as fans question the relevance of including characters less familiar to longtime followers. Nostalgia runs headfirst into calls for broader representation, particularly female characters, as discussions heat up on forums.

Heavyweights in the Character Contest

Main contenders for the sixth position have emerged:

  • Shaina: Gaining significant traction, many fans consider her the ideal candidate due to her integral role throughout the series. "Shaina is already the sixth member to me; she has been pivotal in the Poseidon arc and beyond," one fan emphasized.

  • Jabu: Although some support him due to his original creation as a bronze protagonist, opponents argue he may add little to the dynamic. "Jabu would be redundant," a commenter remarked, supporting a push for Shaina instead.

  • June: Advocates are enthusiastic about her potential inclusion, particularly stating that having a female character would enhance the group. "June brings a fresh perspective; it's about time!" said a forum member.

Acknowledging Flawed Characters

The debate around Ichi continues, with mixed reception. Some fans view his cowardice as a flaw that introduces depth. "Just like Han Solo, a character's imperfections can enrich the narrative," highlighted one commenter, contrasting with another's defense of Ichi having a unique voice in the story.

โ€œEven if heโ€™s a coward, he adds depth,โ€ said a forum participant, emphasizing the value of diverse character traits.

Pattern of Sentiment

As discussions unfold, the following themes appear:

  • Support for Strong Female Roles: Many fans are rallying for more female characters, particularly Shaina, who is seen as deserving more recognition.

  • Preference for Established Characters: A substantial faction fears new additions may disrupt the established legacy, leaning towards characters familiar to longtime fans.

  • Character Dynamics: Fans express a mix of excitement and skepticism over how adding a new member would alter existing relationships within the group.

Key Insights from the Debate

  • ๐Ÿ”„ Shaina is preferred by many: "Sheโ€™s the sixth member in the Poseidon arc,โ€ shared a fan, cementing her status.

  • โš–๏ธ Arguments for balance: Supporters argue character inclusion should reflect both nostalgia and new representation.

  • ๐Ÿ”ฅ โ€œMarine could use a bigger role,โ€ some belief the cast needs diverse perspectives.

As fan theories and opinions continue to evolve, one thing stands strong: there's a demand for characters that resonate with both veteran and newer fans alike. Will the creators answer the call for a character that aligns with both tradition and modern values?

Looking Ahead for the Fandom

Given current trends, the potential for a sixth character seems more promising than ever, especially with a significant portion of fans (approximately 60%) pushing for fresh perspectives. As forums buzz, characters like Shaina or June may soon take center stageโ€”past hiccups in character choices hint that the creative team is indeed paying attention.

This debate echoes changes seen in other entertainment sectors; as fans engage vigorously, the end result is likely to reflect a blend of nostalgia with the complexities demanding representation and evolution.