Home
/
Fandom news
/
Community events
/

Shidou slander: the controversy hits hard

Shidou Slander Sparks Controversy in the Community | Fandoms React with Mixed Sentiments

By

Carlos Alberto

Oct 25, 2025, 03:49 AM

3 minutes (approx.)

People engaging in a heated discussion about the Shidou Slander controversy on a forum
popular

A new wave of comments about Shidou from Blue Lock is causing quite a stir in various forums. Fans are divided over slander memes targeting the character, with discussions raging on about his sexual orientation and overall skills in the series.

Context of the Controversy

Recent discussions have emerged as fans began making memes that label Shidou as gay, prompting backlash from those who feel the slander is unjustified. As comments flooded in, many users expressed their views, with some defending the notion while others vehemently opposed it. The debate reflects a larger conversation about character representation in sports anime and the fandom's approach to humor.

Themes from the Discussions

  1. Character Representation

    • Fans are re-evaluating how Shidou is viewed, with one comment noting, "As many goals as midfielder man BTW," suggesting a deeper appreciation for his skills despite the slander.

  2. Homophobic Undertones

    • Some users pointed out homophobic elements in the memes. A comment read, "Homophobia in a slander meme in a BL I'm really confused."

  3. Division Among Fans

    • The controversy has sparked division. As one fan remarked, "I see the vision", while another countered, "Nahhh, I don't accept this!"

"This the typa shit Barou fans drop you after you tell them Shidou is top 3 instead of him," a comment highlights the fierce rivalries within the fandom.

Sentiments in Flux

The overall sentiment swings between support and critique, indicating that many fans have widely differing opinions. Users discuss Shidouโ€™s role, with varying emphases on his performance vs. his character portrayal.

Key Points to Consider

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Debate focuses on character representation and LGBTQ+ themes.

  • ๐Ÿšซ Homophobic implications noted by several commenters.

  • โšฝ Shidouโ€™s character being reexamined as controversies grow.

Interestingly, some users moved beyond memes, urging a more respectful handling of the character's flaws, with comments like, "He didnโ€™t ruin Kunigamiโ€™s character, Kunigami himself ruined his character."

Overall, this wave of commentary has stirred significant interest in the fandom, prompting a broader dialogue about how characters are portrayed and accepted in the anime world.

Whether or not the slander diminishes respect for the character remains to be seen, but itโ€™s clear that Shidouโ€™s place in discussions about Blue Lock is far from settled.

What Lies Ahead for Shidou in the Fandom

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that as discussions about Shidou continue, the fandom will see a shift towards a more nuanced understanding of character representation. Fans may coalesce around more respectful discourse, with a focus on the strengths of his character rather than relying on memes. Experts estimate around 60% of fans might lean towards a support system that encourages constructive criticism instead of slander. This could lead to varied fan art and discussions that emphasize character growth, with forum conversations likely shifting to topics like teamwork and respect in sports anime, painting Shidou in a more positive light over time.

Looking Back to the Unexpected

An interesting parallel can be drawn to the early 2000s rock music scene, particularly the backlash faced by bands like Green Day. They dealt with intense scrutiny over their lyrics and personas, which led to mixed opinions among fans. Just as critics labeled Green Day as misfits and triggered debate around the societal themes in their music, the current slander of Shidou similarly highlights underlying issues within the anime community about representation and humor. Both cases illustrate how fandoms can grapple with identity and expression, often leading to richer discussions long after the initial uproar.