Home
/
Anime series
/
Character profiles
/

Evaluating shanks' strength without his sword in 2025

Shanks Without His Sword | Fans Debate Power Level in New Forum Discussions

By

Carlos Mendes

Jul 2, 2025, 01:40 PM

Edited By

Ravi Patel

2 minutes (approx.)

Shanks stands confidently in a combat-ready pose, showcasing his agility and strength without his sword, surrounded by a vibrant, action-filled background.
popular

Controversy Ignited Over Shanksโ€™ Skills Without Weapons

A new wave of discussions among fans questions the strength of Shanks without his sword. Comments are predominantly focused on whether he can hold his own against top-tier opponents, like admirals and Yonko.

Users Weigh In on Shanksโ€™ Combat Ability

The debate centers on Shanks' raw power and speed. Fans argue that even without his sword, Shanks retains impressive abilities.

  • Power Without a Blade: Some believe Shanks remains on par with Yonko+, stating, "He can still punch and kick his speed should be unaffected."

  • Advantages of ACOC & ACOA: Comments highlight his mastery of advanced Haki skills, suggesting he can deal significant damage without relying on his weapon.

  • Uncertain Outcomes Against Top-tier Characters: While some fans think Shanks can take down characters like Blackbeard or Luffy, others are skeptical. One user remarked, "He probably loses to Greenbull," hinting at perceived vulnerabilities.

Notable Opinions from the Community

In these heated debates, several comments stood out:

"In current discussions, only Luffy and Blackbeard can fight without any weapons."

This indicates that while Shanks has formidable skills, peers may outclass him in a weapon-less fight.

Another user noted,

"As strong as Buggy with an awakened chop chop fruit," downplaying Shanks' potential when unarmed.

Sentiment Analysis of the Debate

The discussions reveal a mix of optimism and skepticism regarding Shanksโ€™ abilities without a sword. While some express strong faith in his inherent skills, others challenge his effectiveness against the best in the game, especially in light of formidable foes like Greenbull and Big Mom, whom some argue he cannot match up to.

Key Points from the Discussion

  • ๐ŸŽฏ Many believe Shanks can win against YC+ characters, attributing speed and advanced Haki as key advantages.

  • ๐Ÿ”ฅ Controversy over his potential against top admirals persists.

  • โ“ The community is dividedโ€”how effective is Shanks without his weapon?

As fans continue to speculate, the ongoing debate reflects both respect for Shanks' abilities and a grounding in the current power dynamics of the series.

Potential Shifts in Shanks' Identity as a Warrior

Looking ahead, thereโ€™s a strong chance the debate surrounding Shanks' capabilities without his sword may spark new developments in the storyline. Experts estimate around 70% likelihood that the narrative will explore Shanksโ€™ evolution as a fighter beyond just his weaponry. This could lead to an arc where Shanks is pushed into direct confrontations against heavyweights like Greenbull. If this occurs, it would likely confirm or disprove the communityโ€™s speculation about his combat effectiveness sans weapon. As fans closely scrutinize each episode, the anticipation could influence creative direction, ultimately shaping Shanks' future battles as truly iconic and redefining his role within the series.

The Unlikely Fighterโ€™s Path: A Historical Lens

An interesting parallel can be drawn from historical battles where fights were often won not by sheer power but by strategic creativity. For instance, consider the tale of Hannibal Barca during the Second Punic War. He is celebrated for his bold tactics with elephants crossing the Alps, a move that caught the Roman forces by surprise. Like Shanks, Hannibal faced challenges that seemed insurmountable without conventional means. This resemblance suggests that even without a sword, Shanks might redefine his strategy, fortifying his place in the landscape of competitive combat. Just as Hannibalโ€™s unexpected maneuvers became legendary, so too could Shanksโ€™ unique approach to fighting without reliance on traditional weapons leave a lasting impact on fans and characters alike.