Shanks vs. Roger: The Fan Debate Heats Up | Power Dynamics Under Scrutiny

The conversation around Shanks and Roger's strength ignites passionate discussions on forums. Recent comments lean toward the belief that Shanks not only competes with but may surpass the legendary Pirate King. Fans reference Haki mastery, speed, and swordsmanship to support this view.

Haki Mastery: A Game Changer

Recent discussions reinforce that Shanks excels in the Haki arena. Some commenters assert, "Shanks has arguably surpassed Roger," citing strong Haki abilities that include Advanced Conqueror's Haki and unique techniques like Haki projection, DF suppression, and Observation Killing. Shanks' technique, Kamusari, has drawn admiration too, suggesting he potentially outmatches Roger in Haki.

"Nothing in particular, just slightly slower, weaker, less powerful and less durable," expressed a critical commenter, casting doubt on Shanks without his arm.

Swordsmanship: A Duel of Legends

Comments highlight that Shanks' sword skills might match those of Mihawk, bolstering claims that he could rival or even outshine Roger's abilities. A user noted, "Shanks arguably surpassed Roger with his swordsmanship, capable of matching Hawk-Eye, who is world-renowned as the best swordsman."

Speed: Lightning Fast

Shanks' speed is another facet where fans particularly shine a light. Notably, he showcased remarkable agility during battles like Marineford, with one user remarking on his capacity: "He is one of the fastest OP characters." Comparisons during past battles reinforce the sentiment that Shanks can navigate combat swiftly, enhancing his overall effectiveness.

Mixed Feelings in the Community

The community remains divided. While many fans vocalized their support for Shanks, skepticism surfaced regarding how his lost arm might affect his overall strength. Despite doubts, most comments lean positively, arguing that the gap between Shanks and Roger narrows with every new arc.

Key Observations

• 🔥 Shanks possibly has all necessary skills to rival or surpass Roger.

• ⚔️ His sword skills are on par with the finest, indicating potential superiority over Roger.

• ⚡ Shanks' impressive speed enhances his combat portfolio significantly.

As discussions around Shanks and Roger continue to unfold, fans eagerly anticipate crucial moments in the One Piece saga that will further clarify Shanks’ position in the series.