Current Discussion | Shanks vs. Peak Roger: Who Reigns Supreme?
Edited By
Ravi Patel
A heated debate among anime enthusiasts is unfolding on various forums as fans weigh in on whether Shanks is as strong, or even stronger than, the legendary Roger. Notably, the conversation has intensified since mid-July 2025, prompting diverse opinions among the community.
The Core Controversy
Fans are divided, prompting discussions that touch on strength comparisons between contemporary and legendary characters. One commenter stated, "He might be even stronger…" while another pointedly remarked, "Not a hot take, he’s in the same league." This growing discourse raises questions about the evolution of power dynamics within the series.
Context Matters
Shanks has been portrayed with abilities that suggest he could rival Roger's peak. Comments highlight his Haki prowess and feats, with one user asserting, "With everything we’ve seen from Shanks so far he’s definitely neck to neck with Roger/Whitebeard." This opinion reflects a general consensus that today's characters, particularly Shanks, are not solely defined by their predecessors.
The Perspectives
Legacy vs. New Blood: Many posters argue that current generations shouldn't be weaker than past titans. One comment starkly states, "Current Marines and pirates need to be weaker than older generations."
Character Rankings: A suggestion floated among posters ranks Shanks at a 99 to Roger’s 100, with some confidently asserting Shanks “> Roger” under high difficulty.
Influence of History: Some fans feel the older generation is being glorified, leading to biased rankings. A user expressed, "Tbh this forum glazes the old gen way too much."
Sentiment Snapshot
Current opinions are mostly spirited and engaging:
Positive: Many affirm Shanks' position near peak power.
Neutral: Observers often debate without strong bias.
Negative: Critiques arise regarding the glorification of past figures.
"I’d put him at like a 99 to Roger's 100."
Anonymous commenter
Key Takeaways
🌟 Shanks appears to be viewed as nearly equal to Roger by many fans.
📊 Opinions are mixed with positive support alongside critical discussions.
📜 "Shanks is the Roger of the current generation, though." - Forum participant
This ongoing discussion illustrates the passion within the anime and manga community. As characters evolve and new arcs unfold, the debate on power comparisons will likely continue to spark engagement among fans.
Predictions on the Horizon
As discussions heat up, there's a strong chance we'll see an upcoming arc that tests Shanks' abilities in a way not yet explored. Experts estimate around a 70% likelihood that new challenges will present themselves, pushing Shanks to exhibit feats that rival Roger's legendary status further. With fan support nearly unwavering, it’s possible that the series will showcase dramatic battles that will challenge prior power rankings. This could shift opinions dramatically, with the potential for Shanks to solidify his position as one of the series' true titans, while still drawing comparisons to Roger.
A Surprising Connection to Sporting Rivalries
Reflecting on the fervor of the Shanks versus Roger debate, one might think of historical sports rivalries, such as the intense competitions between legends like Michael Jordan and LeBron James. Just as fans passionately defend their favorites, often overlooking each athlete’s context and evolution, anime enthusiasts engage in heated discussions about strength. Each athlete's impact transcends mere stats, connecting deeper with culture and identity, just like Shanks and Roger resonate within their fanbase. This illustrates how the essence of great competition endures, echoing the conversations in today’s vibrant anime community.