Debate Heats Up Over Shanks and Gol D. Roger's Haki | Rivalry or Respect?
Edited By
Carlos Mendoza
A fierce discussion has sparked in forums surrounding the strength comparison between Shanks and Gol D. Roger, now ongoing since April 18, 2025. Many people are questioning whether Shanks truly holds a superiority in either strength or haki against the legendary Gold Roger, despite his impressive feats in the current arc.
The Context Behind the Controversy
As people dissect Shanks' power level, they point out Roger's extraordinary abilities during his prime, especially his balance against figures like Whitebeard. These discussions are buttressed by recent analyses that suggest Shanks, with his background and training, could have attributes surpassing Roger's.
Themes Emerging from User Discussions
Technique Development: Some argue that Shanks has refined his haki skills, possibly at a level Roger never exhibited.
Mentorship Influence: Shanks had formidable mentors like Roger and Rayleigh, leading people to suggest Shanks could have inherited superior techniques.
Current Feats Versus Historical Power: Debate boils down to Shanks' modern achievements conflicting with Roger’s historic prowess.
"Shanks probably wants to at least be stronger than Roger, so he probably analyzed what made him strong, and what he himself could improve on," one forum comment noted.
Voices in the Discussion
Many comments present varied sentiments. One user declared, "We know Shanks was able to copy some of Roger's moves from a young age." Another added, "Shanks has shown the best Haki feats in the series." In contrast, others believe it’s too early to claim superiority over Roger based on current feats alone.
Key Highlights
⚔️ Mentorship: Shanks benefitted from guidance of several past legends.
🔥 Feats Analysis: Many agree Shanks has notable haki skills but question whether that truly equates to overall strength.
🚀 Next Steps: Fans are eager for upcoming arcs to clarify these controversies, especially the portrayal of Roger's current abilities.
Which side will come out on top when more of Roger’s power is revealed? The excitement surrounding this debate seems poised to continue for quite some time.