Home
/
Anime series
/
Character profiles
/

Roger and whitebeard ranked: shanks, oden, and rocks

Tension Surges in Fandom | Roger and Whitebeard Take Top Spots

By

Carlos Ramirez

Aug 30, 2025, 12:42 PM

Edited By

Tanya Lee

2 minutes (approx.)

An illustration showing Roger and Whitebeard at the top of a pirate ranking chart, with Shanks, Oden, and Rocks below them

The discussion heats up among fans about the ranking of major characters in a popular narrative. Notably, Roger and Whitebeard dominate the top positions, stirring debate over the placement of others like Rocks, Shanks, and Oden. This contention highlights the ever-evolving dynamics in character power levels.

Recent Developments

In a recent forum exchange, many commenters expressed their views on the recent reveal of character rankings. According to some, creator Eiichiro Oda might face pressure to reorder silhouettes to satisfy the vocal powerscalers. A user lamented, "Oda when he realizes that he now needs to put the silhouettes in certain orders to please the powerscalers." This reflects a growing concern among fans regarding narrative stability as different factions within the fandom vie for recognition of their favorite charactersโ€™ strengths.

The Community's Split Sentiment

Diving into the comments, we find three significant themes:

  1. Hierarchy Revisions

    Fans are calling attention to how character placements need careful consideration to maintain balance. One commenter stated, "The entire narrative of the scene is that the 5 Kaido are on a similar level; there is no stronger or weaker."

  2. Desire for Peace

    Long-time followers of the series feel that constant debate disrupts enjoyment. As one user pointed out, "This is the ONLY way in which peace could ever be established in this damn wasteland."

  3. Clarity Needed

    Thereโ€™s a collective desire for clearer guidelines on these rankings to foster a better understanding among fans.

"This sets dangerous precedent for character placements," mentioned a top commenter, shedding light on the seriousness of these debates.

Key Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿšฉ The dialogue reveals ongoing disputes over character ranks.

  • ๐Ÿ“Š "There is no stronger or weaker among the five now," notes a user perspective.

  • โœŠ Many agree that clarity is vital for unity within the fandom.

While some fans celebrate these updates, others are left wondering how much longer this back-and-forth can continue without impacting their love for the series.

Stay tuned as this narrative unfolds, and the community continues to grapple with these shifts. Will Oda's next moves quell or fuel the debates?

A Rocky Road Ahead for Rankings in the Fandom

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that the discussions surrounding character rankings will intensify as fans continue to voice their opinions. Given the amount of engagement on forums, it's likely we will see creator Eiichiro Oda address these concerns, perhaps through a future chapter or special event. Experts estimate around a 60% probability that Oda will rearrange rankings to appease fans, which could lead to a temporary harmony. However, with entrenched factions within the community, a lasting resolution remains uncertain. Fans should prepare for the reality that these debates could both enrich and complicate their experience of the series.

History Rhymes in Unexpected Ways

This situation bears a striking resemblance to the infamous debates during the early days of professional sports leagues, where fans rallied around their teams' rankings. Just as baseball fans argued over who deserved the MVP award, anime fans are now finding themselves entrenched in a similar struggle over character rankings. The passionate exchanges in each arena stem from a deep love for the subject, showcasing how fandom can create an alternate world of debate and camaraderie, even when it risks overshadowing the enjoyment of the gameโ€”or in this case, the series itself.