Kazuhiko Torishima Sparks Controversy | Saint Seiya Anime Praised Over Manga
Kazuhiko Torishima's recent comments on Saint Seiya have triggered heated debates among fans. He claims the anime is better than the manga, prompting a divided response on various forums. Many fans feel the changes in character portrayal and story direction detract from the source material.
Context of the Debate
Torishima speaks highly of the anime’s direction, crediting it to figures like Morishita and Koyama. However, a range of fans argue that it neglects the core elements of Kurumada's narrative, leading to ongoing discussions about its creative direction.
Key Themes Emerging from Fan Reactions
Character Portrayal Argument
Fans are divided on whether the anime effectively showcases characters. One fan commented, "Only Seiya and Shiryu’s cloths improved; the rest didn’t do justice." Critics particularly point out that Saori/Athena is often depicted as a damsel in distress, which "reduces her strength."
Production Credit Dispute
While some raise Morishita and Koyama's contributions, others believe Shingo Araki and Michi Himeno deserve more recognition. One fan noted how the production streamlined plot holes: "They fixed many retcons, yet the Mecha suits saints brought disappointment."
Musical and Visual Praise
Despite the criticisms, there's widespread appreciation for the soundtrack. "The soundtrack is definitely world-class; I would listen to it for life without complaints," acknowledged a fan. Another remarked, "The bronze cloths looked great starting from the sanctuary arc!"
Notable Quotes from Fans
"The anime reduces Saori to a passive character, failing to show her strength."
"The beautiful character designs keep me coming back to Saint Seiya."
"They streamlined many plot holes, yet the mecha suits saints weren’t great."
Mixed Sentiments Among Fans
Overall, fans reflect a blend of admiration and frustration. Many celebrate the anime's artistic style while defending the manga's narrative depth. This ongoing dialogue showcases the passionate opinions within the Saint Seiya community.
Key Takeaways
🔥 Many argue the anime diminishes key characters’ credibility.
🎶 High regard for the anime's musical score remains a highlight.
◼️ Continued debates about creative credits and character portrayals persist.