Garp's Call to Action | Analyzing Alternative Warlords for Luffy's Capture
Edited By
Liam O'Connor
In a recent analysis, fans explored the hypothetical scenario of Garp seeking other warlords to capture his grandson, Luffy. While it’s known that Mihawk was present at Baratie by coincidence, discussion sparked on who would be the best alternative choice and what that means for Luffy's fate.
Context of Garp's Request
Garp, a top Marine figure, is known for his formidable reputation. The question raised was simple yet intriguing: what if he had called on other warlords to retrieve Luffy? Each character comes with unique strengths and potential risks, making the debate lively among fans.
Top Choices and Their Implications
Kuma: The Reliable
Kuma tops the list as the most straightforward option. "He can extract the target fast after, unharmed, and deliver it easily," one fan pointed out. His loyalty to Garp means he's likely to follow orders without question.
Jinbe: The Diplomat
Jinbe could serve as a second option, especially since he was still in good standing politically. Contributors suggested that he might take longer and prioritize minimal damage, yet "he won’t kill all the Straw Hats," making him a safe bet.
Mihawk: The Unpredictable
Surprisingly, Mihawk's inclusion raised concerns. His reputation as a powerful warlord is countered with uncertainty about his compliance. Discussions included his tendency to operate independently, "I feel Mihawk was the right choice he’s the only warlord who’d be interested enough in going after Luffy."
Lower-Tier Choices
Other suggestions included:
Boa Hancock: Many doubt her willingness, noting she might hang up on Garp.
Doflamingo: Seen as unpredictable, he could potentially escalate the situation.
Crocodile: Prospective concerns surround his violent tendencies, raising doubts about the safety of Luffy.
Moria: Labeled unreliable, his laziness and penchant for chaos make him undesirable for such a mission.
Diverging Opinions
Fans expressed mixed feelings about these choices. A contributor mentioned, "Kuma and Jinbe would do it the most efficiently and without hurting anyone who doesn't attack them first." Meanwhile, skepticism surrounding Doflamingo and Moria's characters emphasized the unpredictability of their actions if approached by Garp.
Takeaways from the Debate
△ Fans agree that Kuma is the safest choice for a successful mission.
▽ Jinbe could potentially balance safety and efficiency.
※ "Doflamingo likes to toy with the weak," remarked another, highlighting the risks he presents.
The conversation around Garp’s potential calls to these warlords illustrates the intricate dynamics at play within the series. Each warlord's character adds nuances to the possibility of capturing Luffy safely, making the prospect both entertaining and nerve-wracking.
In an ever-active fanbase, the curiosity about which warlord Garp would actually choose continues to stir debate, as players in the One Piece universe evolve and create new narratives.
Future Scenarios for Garp's Choices
There’s a strong chance that if Garp were to recruit Kuma or Jinbe, he could achieve his goal with minimal collateral damage to Luffy’s crew. Experts estimate around a 70% probability that Kuma would act swiftly and decisively, given his known loyalty to Garp. Jinbe, with a probability of about 50%, might prioritize a diplomatic approach, allowing for the possibility of an alternate resolution rather than direct confrontation. In contrast, if Garp pulled in Mihawk, the unpredictability heightens, placing success rates at roughly 40%. Overall, Garp's decision-making will hinge on how he balances the safety of his grandson against the effectiveness of each warlord, setting the stage for potential conflict or cooperation.
An Unexpected Reflection in Historical Strategy
In a somewhat surprising connection, think back to the strategic decisions made by ancient rulers who had to choose their most trusted generals. For instance, Emperor Augustus faced the daunting task of enlisting generals with varied reputations, some known for their fierce loyalty while others were unpredictable. His choice between aggressive expansion and cautious engagement echoes Garp's own dilemma with warlords. Just as Augustus had to weigh the strengths and flaws of his commanders to shape the future of Rome, Garp's selection of warlords could reshape not only Luffy's fate but also the broader narrative within the One Piece universe.