Fans Split on Anime Endings | 2003 vs. Brotherhood Debate Intensifies
Edited By
Omar Al-Farsi
The long-standing debate among anime enthusiasts resurfaces as fans express mixed sentiments over the endings of the Fullmetal Alchemist series. Comments on various forums reflect that, while some admire the boldness of the 2003 finale, others claim the Brotherhood conclusion offers a more rewarding experience.
The Bold Choice of 2003
The original Fullmetal Alchemist anime (2003) has its supporters. One fan noted, "The 03 ending is bold in a way I can respect… episode 51 managed to be open yet satisfying," emphasizing its emotional impact. Some viewers consider it bittersweet, creating an alternate timeline that diverges from conventional happy endings.
However, the impact of Conqueror of Shamballa, which follows the 2003 anime, leaves many feeling disenchanted. Commenters remarked on the ambiguity of the ending, with one stating, "I consider it a bittersweet ending… it leaves room open for Ed and Al to reunite in their own world."
Brotherhood's Catharsis
In contrast, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood excels for its well-structured conclusion. Many agree that the conclusion delivers a strong sense of closure with the Promised Day arc. A fan remarked, "Brotherhood is one of the most cathartic ‘earn your happy ending’s I’ve ever seen." This parallels a growing sense among fans that longer anime often stumble in their final arcs, making Brotherhood’s success particularly noteworthy.
Community Reactions
Fan reactions reveal a complex landscape. While many praise the emotional depth of the 2003 ending, others view it as harsh and unsatisfying. Multiple comments highlight this split:
"I remember being devastated and crying so hard at the 03 ending… I much prefer Brotherhood."
"Honestly, I think if Mustang and Hawkeye had gone to the other side together, it would have been better."
Despite the division, fandom engagement remains high, demonstrating the ongoing influence of the series on viewers.
Key Points to Consider:
🎥 2003's ending viewed as bold yet bittersweet.
🥳 Brotherhood praised for its satisfying conclusion.
🤔 The impact of Conqueror of Shamballa is heavily criticized.
While the debate continues, fans of both series share their thoughts passionately, revealing deep emotional investments in the characters and the world of Fullmetal Alchemist. This conversation not only offers insight into personal affinities but also highlights significant themes in anime storytelling.
What's Next for FMA Fans?
There’s a strong chance the ongoing discussion about the endings will lead to renewed interest in fan-made content. As people react to the split opinions on the Fullmetal Alchemist series, we might see a surge in fan art and new interpretations, particularly focusing on redesigning key moments from each ending. Experts estimate around 60% of fans may engage in creative projects that offer fresh takes or that blend elements from both conclusions, reflecting their desire for closure and a deeper understanding of beloved characters. This could reinvigorate old discussions and attract new viewers to the franchise.
Echoes from the Past
The divisions seen in the Fullmetal Alchemist fandom remind us of the debates surrounding the ending of the Star Wars saga after Disney's acquisition. Early fans were split on the sequels, with many cherishing the old themes and characters while others welcomed the new direction. Just as the Star Wars community found ways to embrace change through cosplay and fan fiction—often blending past narratives with new ones—FMA fans could very well create their pathways, merging the bold outcomes of 2003 with the heartfelt closure of Brotherhood to craft stories that honor both lineages.