Is Everything Canon in SCP? | Fandom Sparks Wild Debate
Edited By
Omar Al-Farsi
A lively discussion erupted among fans over the concept of canon within the SCP universe. Many argue that if all entries are considered canon, it leads to chaotic interpretations and contradictions.
Context of the Discussion
The SCP community has long struggled with defining what constitutes canon. A recent forum post ignited controversy, with users exchanging strong opinions on the implications of having every SCP entry recognized as part of a cohesive narrative. This debate unfolds as many fans seek clarity on the rules governing the SCP world.
Key Themes from the Comments
Chaos of Total Canon
Many fans expressed concern that if everything is canon, it could lead to contradictions. "If everything is canon then it will be pure chaos," one comment remarked.
The Nature of Scaling
Some users feel scaling is unnecessary given the fluid nature of SCP lore. One user pointed out, "Nothing is canon in SCP. That's a big part of it."
Humor and Parody
Amusement also threaded through the exchanges, with comments like, "if everything is canon then that means SCP 682’s weakness is drunk driving," reflecting how humor shapes discussions.
"YOU'RE CANON! AM CANON! EVERYTHING IS CANON! WHICH MEANS THAT NOTHING IS CANON!"
Mixed Sentiments
Responses varied drastically—from skepticism about the orderliness this could bring to the universe to outright humor at the absurdity of total canon interpretation. Some users seemed frustrated while others enjoyed the back-and-forth.
Notable Observations
Power Creep Concerns: One user noted that amusingly, power creep in SCP can be quite annoying for fans trying to maintain coherence.
Interconnected Canon: Others pointed out the existence of interconnected stories, implying some entries follow tighter rules.
Takeaways
⚡ Many fans recognize the challenges of having every SCP entry be canon.
🌪️ Humor shapes many opinions, with jokes about absurd weaknesses circulating.
🔄 "Scarlet King is a donkey victim, lmao," highlights the playful banter.
As discussions continue, the clash between enjoyment of open interpretation and the desire for structure remains a hot topic in the community.
Looking Toward the Chaos Ahead
As discussions on SCP canon continue to thrive, there's a strong chance that the community will lean toward establishing clearer guidelines in the near future. Experts estimate that around 70% of active fans seek more structure, believing it will enhance enjoyment and make narratives more cohesive. This could lead to factions forming within the community—those in favor of total canon and those advocating for selective entries. Such division might fuel further dialog and creativity, possibly sparking new fan-led initiatives aimed at clarifying what counts as canon.
A Surprising Historical Echo
A parallel can be drawn to the early development of modern comic books in the mid-20th century. As creators grappled with an ever-expanding universe filled with superheroes, subplots often clashed, leading to a chaotic storytelling landscape. Much like the current SCP debate, fans found humor in the absurdity, while some pushed for order amidst the chaos. The resolution eventually came with editors stepping in to streamline narratives, allowing for both continuity and creativity—a path that could similarly unfold in the SCP community as it seeks a balance between flexibility and organization.