What If Eren Didn't Kill His Mom? | Fan Theories Heat Up in Fandoms
As debates ignite in multiple forums, fans are asking: what if Eren hadn’t killed his mother? Discussions center on how this pivotal moment shaped the series and Eren's character.
The Intriguing Context
Eren Jaeger’s mission against Titans springs from deep trauma, particularly the loss of his mother, Carla. Many argue this event fueled his quest for revenge, and without it, everything changes. Fans are split on the potential implications of a different timeline.
Contrasting Views from the Community
Among various user boards, opinions on this scenario are vivid and passionate. One user noted that without time travel, "Carla still dies" due to the Titans invading their home.
"Hannes would probably still be able to save Eren; either way, that wouldn’t change anything," they explained, reflecting on Eren’s survival without his mother's influence.
Another commenter speculated, "If he doesn’t see Carla get eaten, he might just let go of his anger”—suggesting a possible shift in his motivations. With the series' complex time mechanics, fans believe Eren's character narrative could take multiple turns.
Key Themes Emerging from the Discussion
Timeline Integrity: The possibility of altering key events raises concerns about damaging the story’s coherence.
Character Fate: Fans are debating whether Eren would morph into a hero or remain an anti-hero without Carla’s death influencing him.
Fictional Possibilities: Some fans welcome exploring alternative timelines, viewing them as a creative opportunity, regardless of how speculative they might seem.
Sentiment Insights
The sentiment is varied. While many fans threaten to dismiss these hypotheticals outright, others are excited to envision creative alternatives. Notably, one user quipped, "Some people are incapable of understanding hypotheticals," suggesting that some discussions veer towards undue convolutedness.
Takeaways
⚔️ Altering Eren's past could erase the series’ emotional core.
🌀 "There’s another royal blood shifter around for Eren," a fan mentioned, implying a potential shift in power dynamics.
🤔 ";Grisha wouldn’t have given Eren the Attack Titan" highlights skepticism about Eren's potential without his traumatic past.
In summary, what happens to Eren without this defining tragedy remains a hot topic in the community. As fans continue to explore these alternate narratives, it’s clear their investment in the storyline is still robust, prompting a deeper look into every possibility.