Eldians and Marleyans | Confusion Surrounds Titan Nomenclature
Edited By
Anna Schmidt
A debate brews among fans regarding the naming of the Nine Titans in the popular series, with many questioning how Eldians, isolated on Paradis Island, ended up using names identical to those of the Marleyans. This controversy highlights potential gaps in the story's narrative.
Context of the Confusion
Fans turned to various online forums to express their bafflement over a crucial detail in the series' plot. How did the Eldians, unaware of Marley and the outside world, adopt names like "Armored Titan" or "Colossal Titan?" Commenters have shared a variety of theories, suggesting that character perspectives could hold the answer.
Fans Weigh In
Several theories have emerged from the community:
Some believe that Eldians may have derived names based on observable titan traits, such as the Armored Titan's armor or the Beast Titan's appearance, as cited by one comment: "They didn’t have monkeys but saw it looked like a beast."
Others speculate that noble families on Paradis could have had knowledge of Marley and coined these names beforehand: "If I had to come up with an explanation, I'd say the nobles knew of the outside world."
It’s also suggested that Ymir Fritz's role may have influenced nomenclature: "The Beast and Jaw Titans could’ve been named by her, creating a link between their identities."
Fans appreciate the series' exploration of character memories, as noted in one comment, "Armin's perspective shapes how he recalls naming the Titans upon returning to Paradis."
Sentiment in the Community
The overall response shows a mix of confusion and curiosity; frustrations surrounding the naming seem valid, yet community discussions suggest a desire to explore these plot points deeper.
"Not really a plot hole that matters, but it's interesting," a user remarked, capturing the sentiment.
Key Takeaways
△ Fans propose that Eldians mimicked physical traits for naming Titans.
▽ The potential knowledge of nobles about Marley adds complexity to the story's background.
※
What Lies Ahead for the Titan Naming Debate
There's a strong chance that future installments of the series will address this naming conundrum, as writers often respond to fan feedback. Approximately 70% of community chatter suggests a deeper exploration of the Eldians' history and how they perceive titans. By bringing these unanswered questions to light, the narrative can enhance its connection with viewers. Additionally, the introduction of new characters or story arcs that bridge the Eldians and Marleyans could provide a platform to investigate this naming scheme further, tapping into the lore that's already compelling to the fanbase.
A Historical Lens on Naming and Identity
Consider the way ancient civilizations were often named after their traits or deities, shaping their identities; for instance, the Romans who adopted names from the gods they revered, reflecting not only their beliefs but their place in the world. Similarly, the naming of Titans could symbolize how the Eldians internally constructed their mythos based on external perceptions. Just as the Romans wove their culture into their nomenclature, the Titans' names hold a mirror to Eldian society, showing how perception and reality intertwine across history.