User Boards Critique Design Choices | New Comments Reflect Mixed Feelings on Black Clover Artwork
A growing coalition of people is voicing strong opinions about the artistic flaws in the anime series Black Clover. Recent forum discussions highlight ongoing concerns over character designs, with expressions of disappointment and some surprising defenses surfacing.
Context of the Controversy
Discussions continue as fans critique the texture and shading in recent character designs, calling them unrefined. A faction of users indicates this issue is not a one-time error but reflects a recurring problem in the series' art quality.
Key Points of Discussion
Artistic Quality Concerns: People are vocal about the shadow lines, particularly under the chin, which many find lackluster. One person noted, "Those lines under her chin look like a rough draft that made it to the final design."
Design Preferences: Some fans expressed a preference for simpler designs, with one user stating, "Admittedly I'm not a big fan of the post time skip redesigns, I prefer the simpler designs we had."
Acknowledgment of Broader Trends: There’s a recognition that similar design flaws exist across multiple anime. A comment emphasized, "Literally practically every anime does this."
"C'mon, be real, those lines need work!"
– Comment from a user on the forum.
User Reactions and Analysis
Overall, sentiment remains predominantly negative regarding character design among fans, though some still find merit in other aspects of the series. This divide indicates that while frustration exists, the fandom has not abandoned the series entirely.
Curiously, discussions spotlight a specific critique about the eyebrow lines and chin shading, with one saying, "I know it’s supposed to portray texture and depth but damn does it look like a 5th grader drew it."
Key Takeaways
✍️ Many comments focus on the deficiencies in character designs, especially concerning shadows.
✔️ Some users miss simpler designs prior to the recent changes.
🧩 Broader recognition that similar issues are common across anime aesthetics is rising.
As conversations around these design choices continue to evolve, it remains to be seen if creators will respond constructively to this feedback. The community's engagement signals a lively discourse that could influence future artistic direction in the series.