Controversial Manga Opinions | Junji Ito and Berserk Under Fire
As tensions flare in the manga fandom, bold opinions on popular series like Berserk and Junji Ito's works spark heated discussions across forums. This growing discourse reflects a divide, with several people questioning the acclaimed status of these titles, particularly in light of recent comments.
Discontent with Beloved Titles
The controversy began when one participant expressed a lack of appreciation for Ito's storytelling, stating, "I think Junji Ito’s stories for the most part suck." The sentiment gained traction, as several others chimed in with their own criticisms.
Key Themes Emerging from the Debate
Berserk's Artistic Value Questioned: Some contributors feel Berserk, despite its visual appeal, falls flat in narrative depth.
A notable commentary stated, "I sold Berserk once I was done with it but keep Claymore in my collection."
Mixed Feelings on Endings: Some participants shared thoughts on endings from other series, with one declaring, "The Attack on Titan, Gantz, and Promised Netherland endings weren’t that bad at all."
Criticism of Classic Works: Opinions vary widely about established series. A commenter noted, "I 100% agree with Junji Ito. His art is good, but the story is nothing special." This highlights ongoing frustrations with long-standing titles.
A notable commentary stated, "I sold Berserk once I was done with it but keep Claymore in my collection."
Community Sentiment
The blend of opinions ranges from disappointment to analytical observations, with many leaning towards critical reflections on long-beloved titles like Berserk. Several express a desire for more complex character development, questioning whether mainstream popularity equates to quality.
"I’ve only read Uzumaki, but the characters were so underdeveloped I really couldn’t care at all about what was happening to them," shared one frustrated reader.
Participants also explored genre preferences, with someone mentioning that isekai was better as a shojo trope and praising eBooks for their practicality. This hints at a broader discussion around modern consumption of manga.
Key Takeaways
📉 Both Junji Ito’s and Berserk's writing quality under scrutiny; many feel let down.
🔍 Diverse opinions call into question what makes a series 'great'.
🎨 Art is praised, yet storytelling is deemed lacking by several contributors.
📖 Many readers find value in alternative endings, sparking renewed discussions.
This conversation illuminates a critical connection between art and narrative, challenging fans to reevaluate their favorites amidst a wave of dissent.