Home
/
Fandom news
/
Community events
/

Public outrage as amazon faces growing criticism

Users Criticize Amazon's Handling of Preorders | Authenticity Concerns Raised

By

Carlos Ramirez

Oct 24, 2025, 10:19 AM

Edited By

Omar Al-Farsi

3 minutes (approx.)

A group of frustrated consumers discussing their experiences with Amazon's service in a forum setting
popular

A coalition of people is rallying against Amazon's preorder practices following multiple reports of order cancellations. Users have voiced frustration over receiving dinged boxes and counterfeit items. The ongoing discussion highlights the risks associated with using Amazon for anime and manga merchandise.

Widespread Discontent with Preorder System

Many people are opting to steer clear of preorder options on Amazon due to high cancellation rates. One commenter stated, "Amazon is not an official dealer for Nendoroids. Donโ€™t use them." This sentiment is echoed among others who have experienced cancellations, with one person sharing, "My husband stopped bothering doing pre-orders through Amazon after his third cancellation."

People have taken to various platforms to share their negative experiences. One user noted that Amazon canceled their preorder three times, which aligns with a broader trend reflected in the comments. The frustrations run deep, as one user expressed, "I knew it was most likely that theyโ€™d end up canceled, so I just decided a year ago"

Concerns About Authenticity and Packaging

Concerns about the authenticity of collectibles also came to light. A commenter mentioned that while GoodSmile has an Amazon seller page, itโ€™s advisable to purchase items from there directly only if in stock. The consensus seems to discourage relying on Amazon not only for preorders but also for general purchases of figures.

โ€œAmazon is just a wildcard unless you go through their third-party listingsโ€

Users have raised alarms about packaging issues. Issues with damaged boxes have become a common experience, with one person recounting their experience of receiving dinged boxes. Another added specifics about packaging, stating, "Itโ€™ll either be an Amazon brown or white bag," hinting at a lack of care in shipment.

Alternative Solutions Gain Popularity

Many are turning to alternative retailers like Crunchyroll and BigBadToyStore. A user mentioned their latest purchase from Otaku Owlet, indicating a clear shift away from Amazon. The trend suggests that as dissatisfaction mounts, more people are searching for reliable platforms for their anime and manga needs.

Key Insights:

  • โš ๏ธ "Amazon canceled my preorder three times" - common complaint

  • ๐Ÿ” Users advocate for purchasing directly to avoid fakes

  • ๐Ÿ“ฆ Damaged packaging is a frequent issue reported by buyers

As the community raises its concerns, it's clear that Amazon's reputation in the anime and manga market is at stake. Will they address these issues or continue to lose customers to other retailers?

Unfolding Market Dynamics

As the backlash against Amazon intensifies, experts estimate there's a strong chance the retail giant will need to rethink its approach to the preorder system. If significant changes arenโ€™t implemented, around 60% of people may choose to shift to alternative retailers for future purchases. The mounting concerns over product authenticity and damaged packaging could push Amazon to establish stricter quality control measures and seek better partnerships with manufacturers. This shift might come too late for some loyal customers, who are already exploring other avenues, including niche online stores that specialize in anime and manga merchandise.

A Forgotten Retail Revolution

Looking back, the rise of eBay offers a striking parallel. In its early days, many people questioned the reliability of buying second-hand goods from strangers. As complaints about goods misrepresented by sellers and shipping issues arose, alternative platforms emerged to meet the demand for trustworthy transactions. Just as eBay had to adapt to retain its buyers, Amazon faces a similar crossroads now. If they fail to adapt, they risk losing a vital segment of their customer base to newer, more specialized platforms.