Fans Clash Over Cinder's Plot in RWBY | Should She Have Met Her End Earlier?
A growing debate among RWBY fans questions whether Cinder should have been killed off in Volume 3, igniting discussions about character development and narrative choices. New insights from recent comments reveal persistent dissatisfaction with her storyline, with notable criticisms emphasizing missed opportunities for depth.
Cinder's Character Development in Question
The timing of Cinder's backstory release has drawn sharp criticism. One fan stated, "We got her backstory way too late; before that, she was just an evil villain without depth." This viewpoint resonates as many express frustration over how her actions overshadow any potential for character growth.
Another commenter pointed out, "Cinder ignored her chance for vengeance against Ruby to attack Jaune, which felt like a major writing flaw." This idea echoes previous sentiments that Cinder's choices create inconsistencies in her established persona.
Unpacking the Missed Opportunities
Fans in the community argue that earlier development would have made her a more compelling character. A user noted, "It's a writing failure to set her up as sympathetic after she's committed to a path of destruction." Many believe Cinder could still have been used productively without facing an early demise, but only if the writing would have supported that shift.
Issues with Storytelling and Character Arcs
The conversation about Cinder is also linked to broader concerns over RWBY’s storytelling. Commenters lamented that the handling of her character lacks motivation and growth, suggesting that the writers missed crucial chances to evolve her arc while maintaining tension in the story. One fan articulated that the use of Cinder was a strategy to uphold the show's credibility amid controversies, indicating a disconnect between character development and external influences.
"They scored a Major VA to lend legitimacy to the show after the Vic drama."
Fans remain sharply divided on Cinder's place in the narrative, reflecting a mixture of hope for improvement and disappointment regarding current character dynamics.
Key Insights from the Fandom
🔸 Many feel Cinder’s late-character reveal hindered her significance.
▽ The critique emphasizes frustrations over writing decisions.
🔄 An earlier death is seen as a strong narrative move, allowing for more impactful character arcs.
As discussions continue to gain momentum, the direction of Cinder’s character and the fate of other villains remains a hot topic. Fans are now left wondering how RWBY will choose to evolve its storytelling as future volumes unfold.