Brotherhood Character Rankings | Fandom Buzzes with Opinions
The latest character tier list from Brotherhood has sparked a lively debate among fans, with discussions featuring both praise and criticism for various characters. As of July 2025, engagement on forums has reached new heights, particularly regarding the placements of Scar, Winry, and other fan favorites.
Context of the Tier List
The rankings originated from a devoted fan who just wrapped up their Brotherhood viewing. This list triggered intense conversations about character placements, especially Scar's and Winry's rankings.
Key Themes in the Discussion
Scar's Placement Under Scrutiny
Mixed feelings flood the forums over Scar’s second-tier rank. A commenter quipped, "Why is the best character in the series (Scar) on the second tier?" This sentiment resonates with many wishing to see Scar rank higher.
High Praise for Winry
Many users agree that if Winry is ranked high, it likely indicates a solid list.
"If Winry is ranked high, it’s a good list. So - good list 👍." This reflects how Winry's position adds credibility to the tier rankings.
Love for Other Characters
The Chimera gang also received attention, with one fan stating, "I’m happy to see that the Chimera gang are getting some proper love out here, especially my guy Mr Heinkel."
Discussion about other characters, including the Slicer Brothers and Envy, reveals further diverse opinions. One user humorously noted, "If Envy is ranked high, it's a good list. 🤣" while expressing surprise at the low ranking for the Slicer Brothers.
Sentiment Patterns
Comments reflect a blend of appreciation and critique. Scar remains a divisive figure, whereas Winry and characters like Envy bolster support from the community. Overall, passionate attachments to characters shine through the discussions.
Noteworthy Insights
◻️ Scar is seen as needing a higher rank by many commenters.
◻️ Winry's high rank boosts the list's credibility for many.
◻️ The Chimera gang is getting recognition, with fans rallying behind them.
◻️ Discontent about the low placement of characters like the Slicer Brothers stirs curiosity.
As these discussions continue to develop, fresh perspectives and debates are expected to influence future rankings. Could we see a resurgence in collaborative fan content driven by the passionate involvement of people like those expressing their views on forums? Only time will tell as the Brotherhood fandom flexes its engagement muscle.