Home
/
Manga series
/
Genre focus
/

Big mom as mother caramel: a deep dive into theory

Big Mom's Identity in Question | Fans Debate Mother Caramel Connection

By

Chloe Dupont

Oct 22, 2025, 04:50 AM

Edited By

Tanya Lee

Updated

Oct 22, 2025, 04:05 PM

2 minutes (approx.)

A comparison of Big Mom and Mother Caramel, showing their similar features and styles.
popular

A growing number of conversations on forums has reignited speculation about Big Mom's true identity, particularly her connections to Mother Caramel. This discourse stems from recent theories suggesting a deeper relationship between the characters, prompting intense discussions about their respective roles and influences.

New Perspectives on Character Connections

Fans have expressed skepticism over the relevance of these theories, with one user commenting, "I donโ€™t think Kaido and Big Mom are gonna be relevant outside of flashbacks anymore." This sentiment poses questions about the significance of the theories being discussed.

Concerns Over Character Development

Several commenters contend that exploring a soul transfer narrative could undermine Big Mom's character arc. One highlights that such theories "ruin Linlinโ€™s character," while another fan remarks, "Itโ€™s a fun theory but whatโ€™s the point?" This highlights a growing belief that focusing on this aspect does little to contribute to the storyline.

Eminent Debate Over Evidence

The discourse largely revolves around the lack of concrete evidence supporting the soul transfer theory. Users assert, "None of this qualifies as evidence, itโ€™s all pure speculation." Critics emphasize that while theories may sound engaging, they may not align with established character motivations or the current narrative trajectory.

p>Interestingly, comments like "Linlin's original body has been warping under the stress of housing two souls" surface, yet additional context is needed to clarify how this affects her character development significantly and whether it has much bearing on the ongoing story.

The Community's Mixed Sentiment

While many fans remain captivated by the possibility of a hidden connection, a sizeable number remain doubtful. This split in sentiment emphasizes the challenge of reconciling big theories with lifeโ€™s realities in the series.

Key Insights

  • โ–ณ Some fans deem the theories irrelevant given the narrative's direction.

  • โ–ฝ Critics argue that the theories lack grounded evidence.

  • โ€ป "This theory just distracts from the real character growth," noted a commenter.

As fans continue to engage with this topic, the significance of Big Mom's connection to Mother Caramel remains unclear. Could future chapters shed light on these theories, or are they merely distractions in a larger narrative? Only time will tell.

The discussion surrounding Big Mom's identity highlights the fans' investment in character arcs and narrative depth. As the series progresses, the communities' debates over theories reflect the ongoing complexity of storytelling in anime and manga.