Would Chronological Storytelling Elevate Berserk? | Fans Respond
A vibrant discussion is underway regarding whether Berserk would fare better with a chronological narrative. Many fans assert that while a linear structure could draw in casual readers, it might sacrifice the series' raw intensity and unique storytelling.
The Non-Linear Narrative
Beloved for its intricate storytelling, Berserk follows a non-linear format that gradually reveals character backstories. Fans remain divided on the merits of this approach versus a straightforward timeline.
Prologue Status: One fan pointed out, "The Black Swordsman arc is more like a prologue than an actual arc."
Character Growth: Another noted, "If we saw Guts grow up earlier, it might have worked."
Expectations Set: A responder argued, "The Black Swordsman arc sets the audience's expectations for the gritty revenge story, preparing them for the fantasy elements that come later."
Accessibility for New Readers
Many commenters echoed concerns about the series' mature themes making it challenging for newcomers. A fan remarked, "Most people who quit on Berserk did so during the Black Swordsman arc because it’s so crass and edgy." Others maintained that starting with the Golden Age arc provided an alternative way to appreciate the story.
Mixed Reactions on Structure
Sentiments vary, with some defending the original narrative as fitting for its dark themes. Others argue for a conventional structure. A notable quote reflected this: "It’s really not our place to deconstruct a 20+ year old project. I think everything was carefully planned."
Fans drew comparisons to series like Game of Thrones, with one commenter questioning, "Idk about the timeskip from Golden Age to Black Swordsman tho"
What Fans Want
As the debate rages on, fans have mixed feelings about the effectiveness of changing the storytelling format. Many believe that Miura's intent was spot-on, effectively pulling in Western audiences with a blend of mystery and dark themes.
Key Insights
▽ Fans expressed dissatisfaction with the Black Swordsman arc's mature content.
🗨️ "The Black Swordsman arc delays shocking scenes until readers are invested" – a recurring sentiment among commenters.
△ Several fans feel that the story's complexity enhances its allure.
Is Berserk’s narrative style too cherished to change? Fans appear split, but with a strong preference for the depth of Miura’s original work. This enduring debate highlights not only the complexity of the series but also the evolving expectations of its audience.